Which Cities in Florida Have the Highest Crime Rates? Several cities in Florida are known for having higher crime rates. Miami sees a high level of violent crimes such as assault and robbery, while Orlando experiences significant property crimes, particularly theft. Tallahassee has elevated rates of violent crime, and Jacksonville faces notable issues with homicides and aggravated assaults. St. Petersburg and Fort Lauderdale also contend with higher-than-average crime rates, including robberies and violent offenses. Daytona Beach, famous for its beach and motorsports culture, has a crime rate well above the national average, especially in terms of violent crime.